Donate Now  |  Take Action  |  Sign Up
 

About Us
 
Our Work
 
UN Watch Briefing
 
Testimony at the UN
 
Articles
 
Reports
 
Statements & Letters
 
Issues in Focus
 
Media Center
 
Take Action
 
Sign Up
 
Contact Us
 
Internships
 
Donate
 
En français
 
En español
 
       בעברית
 



 

 

  

UN Watch Briefing

Analysis and Commentary from UN Watch in Geneva
Wednesday, 6 December 2000 — Issue 59

News: The High Commissioner for Human Rights Mary Robinson has just issued a report on her 'fact-finding' mission to the Middle East, which was one-sided and unhelpful.

Analysis: People build institutions as an expression of underlying beliefs; in pursuit of efficiency; for durability; as repositories of knowledge. Consider, for example, the United Nations. The Charter creates a series of institutions that reflect mankind's greater purposes - the quest for peace, the eradication of disease and poverty, the protection of human rights.

Of course, with the UN made up of individual states, their interests do not always correspond to some of our more altruistic aspirations. Nevertheless, throughout the UN system, there are thousands of people toiling in service of the values and ideals upon which the UN was founded.

Institutions are also characterized by the fact that, at any given point, individual people must represent them and embody their values. This is a tremendous responsibility, for it calls upon human beings - with all their strengths and weaknesses - to reflect values and to serve something greater and more lasting than any one person can ever be. There is great nobility in this task, and few human endeavors are as humbling or as praiseworthy.

In 1993, the Office of the High Commissioner of Human Rights was established, in large measure, as a coordination center. More subtly, it was also designed to voice human rights concerns worldwide.

However, the effectiveness of the Office as an institution is dependent upon the effectiveness of whoever occupies it at any given time. That person must, to ensure the legitimacy of the institution, act consistently with the standards we wish to see all future occupants demonstrate in all future instances. That is a Herculean task, but it is what is needed to ensure the viability and legitimacy of the institution.

Mrs. Robinson's report on her visit to the Middle East seems to suggest that she had reached her conclusions before stepping off the plane. She lamented Israeli actions without considering why they were taken, and she minimized the fact that Israel has been defending itself from armed attacks. While presuming that Israel was the aggressor, she dismissed its concerns one by one. This is not 'fact-finding,' it is 'fact-deciding.'
 
In our age, when human rights can be used as a sword as much as a shield, it is imperative that every office holder recognize the depth of his or her responsibility. In this case, regrettably, the office holder came up short.

Also Watched This Week…

Ultimate UN violation: The UN has confirmed that UNIFIL uniforms, thought to be used as disguises, were found in the cars of Hizbollah terrorists who kidnapped three Israeli soldiers.

D

Iraq versus UN...again: Iraq has cut off oil exports and is demanding that a 50% surcharge per barrel be deposited into a private Iraqi bank account instead of the UN-controlled account as stipulated by the Security Council.

D

Climate Changed: After two weeks of intense negotiations, attempts to finalize the Kyoto Protocol, guidelines for reducing greenhouse emissions, have been suspended.

D

 





Read our recent editions:

  • Issue 509
  • EU pulls out of anti-Israel UN debate, Islamic states outraged
  • Issue 508
  • UN Watch and 20 North Korean survivors urge Swiss to freeze regime’s bank accounts
  • Issue 507
  • UN Watch Director Lectures at University of Michigan Law School, Says U.N. Rights Council is "Too Welcoming to Rights Abusers"
  • Issue 506
  • William Schabas’ own colleague, human rights icon Aryeh Neier, calls for him to quit UN Gaza probe
  • Issue 505
  • "I see no objection": UN adopts report praising Qatar's human rights record after UN Watch lists objections
  • Issue 504
  • "I was tortured by Russian-backed militants," Ukrainian woman tells UN rights council
  • Issue 502
  • UN Watch Brings Iraqi Christian Woman to Address UN Session on Iraq